From the record · 01
The driver they cleared anyway
Dougherty Equipment Co. v. Roper, 327 Ga. App. 434, 757 S.E.2d 885 (Ga. Ct. App. 2014). Appeal from the denial of the employer's motion for summary judgment on a negligent entrustment claim. Affirmed. A former employee and on-call technician was issued a company van. He was driving it to work when he collided with another driver's vehicle. The injured driver sued the company two ways: vicariously for the driver's negligence, and directly for negligent entrustment.
What the record showed. When the company hired him, it knew his license had been suspended for a 2004 DUI. The company prohibited him from driving a company vehicle, or even his own vehicle, for any business purpose. In February 2007 he received a restricted driving permit. In March 2007, before clearing him to drive again, the company obtained his motor vehicle record. That record showed a 2004 failure to maintain lane conviction and carried the notation "Limited Permit 2DUI." The company cleared him anyway.
What decided it. The Court of Appeals held the notation was "clearly sufficient to create an inference for summary judgment purposes" that the company knew the driver had more than one DUI, counting the 2004 conviction and an earlier one in the late 1990s. On that basis: "there is a question of fact on the issue of negligent entrustment." The case went to a jury. The vicarious claim did not survive. Because the driver was commuting, the coming-and-going rule rebutted the presumption that he was acting within the scope of his employment, even as an on-call technician with a company van. The only theory left standing was the one about the employer's own conduct.
The record this deployment produces. Fleet Command. A signed, dated Driver Qualification File for every driver. A documented annual motor vehicle record review. A binary vehicle-use policy, signed and filed. An Early Warning System that forces a documented 72-hour review of every violation and every record notation, with an escalation threshold that is enforced rather than remembered.
The honest limit. This was not a company that failed to check. It checked, read a two-DUI notation, and cleared the driver to a company van. No documentation system fixes a manager who decides to do that. What a system does is make the decision visible, documented and owned, and make the review happen at all rather than by memory. Documentation cuts both ways. A system that records knowledge and then does nothing with it produces the exact fact pattern that put this case in front of a jury.
A note on state law. Georgia requires actual knowledge, not constructive knowledge, to support negligent entrustment. In Georgia, "we never checked" is closer to a defense than to liability. States that permit constructive knowledge treat the failure to check as the exposure itself. The review discipline matters in both, for different reasons.
